Episode 5.2

CET Talks: Accreditation, Learning and Leadership

Episode 5.2

NOV 18 2026 . 26 MINUTES

The Third Place: Rethinking Learning Environments

Dr. Kelly Heuer joins Randy Bowman and Bradley Davis to discuss how Ray Oldenburg’s concept of the third place can inform professional learning environment design. The conversation considers belonging, accessibility, conversation, community, and how hybrid work has changed informal professional connections.

Listen to the Podcast

Transcription

Host: Welcome to CET Talks, the International Accreditors for Continuing Education and Training’s podcast, where we convene thought leaders in the continuing education and training ecosystem to share ideas, research, best practices, and experiences that promote the creation of a world that learns better. Enjoy the episode.

Randy Bowman: We talk a lot about what people learn, but what about the spaces where learning happens and the people they meet along the way?

Bradley Davis: Think about the places where you feel comfortable showing up, asking a question, or staying just for one more conversation. What if professional learning felt more like that?

Randy Bowman: As hybrid work changes how we connect, those spaces, I think, may be more important than ever.

Bradley Davis: Today, we’re talking about learning as a ‘third place’, at how to design for connection, belonging, and growth. That is today’s CET Talks.

Randy Bowman: Hello, and welcome to CET Talks. I’m Randy Bowman, President and CEO of IACET, and joining me today is my co-host, Bradley Davis.

Bradley Davis: Thank you, sir. My name is Bradley Davis, Vice President of Accreditation and Learning here at IACET, filling in as your substitute co-host for Mike Veny. I’m especially excited about this conversation because learning environments are not just classrooms, platforms, or course materials. They can also shape whether people feel comfortable participating, connecting, and coming back.

Randy Bowman: And our guest today brings a wonderful perspective on what that can mean for the future of professional learning.

Bradley Davis: Our guest today is my good friend, Dr. Kelly Heuer, Vice President of Learning at the Project Management Institute (PMI), where she leads PMI’s Global Learning Division. Her work spans professional standards and publications, live and enterprise training, digital and on-demand learning, and career-long professional development. Before PMI, Kelly served as Vice President of Learning Experience at edX and taught at Georgetown University.  Kelly, welcome to CET Talks.

Dr. Kelly Heuer: Thank you so much. It’s my pleasure to be here.

Randy Bowman: We’re so excited to have you here today, Kelly. So, to get us started, we said we’re going to be talking about a ‘third place’. For our listeners who may not know what that means. Can you start with telling us what a ‘third place’ is?

Dr. Kelly Heuer: So, Randy, this concept actually comes from sociologist Ray Oldenburg, who wrote a blistering excoriation of suburbia and its impact on civic life. That’s how I first encountered his work. Essentially, what he introduces is the notion of a ‘third place’ beyond home and work, where people come together, find community, learn and share, and forge civic connections was a big part of what he was focused on. And in his point of view, suburban planning and urban layouts had eliminated a lot of the natural points of convening, whether that was the barbershop or the coffee shop, that natural connection and mutual understanding were forged in, historically. And so from his point of view, this felt the downfall of democracy.

What it left us with, I think, is a really interesting way of thinking about ‘third places’ as concept for mutual learning, for professional development beyond school, beyond some of those early learning educational experiences. I think about this work a lot, not within the context of suburbia, but within the context of how we can create meaningful connection and foster genuine learning and development for professionals beyond school.

Randy Bowman: It’s a great concept. You know, we all tie back to Cheers and going down to the bar where everybody knows your name. That’s a ‘third place’ and they are missing. As we think about professional learning, a lot of times we focus on “Is the content true and valid? Is the instructor qualified? Do the outcomes that we’re expecting meet the needs that we wanted them to when we did the needs analysis?” How then does this play into that, that the idea that the connections people make along the way fit into learning environments, when we’re talking about this concept of the ‘third place’?

Dr. Kelly Heuer: So I love this question, Randy, because the way that Oldenburg articulates ‘third places’, they almost by definition don’t have a specific purpose beyond gathering. I mean, sure, at a coffee shop, you’re there to get coffee and at a barbershop, you’re there to get your hair cut. But generally, becoming an aggregator where everybody knows your name, where you go to hang out, at least in the way he defined the term, is partly constituted by, you’re not there—I get in, I get out, I do what I came to do. And a lot of the ways, exactly as you’re saying, we think about designing, training, facilitation, a learning platform, a learning experience end-to-end, is extremely goal-driven. It’s literally defined by the learning outcomes. And how do I get people from the level of learning they started with to the level of learning we ended with? And how do I measure that effectively? That’s a lot of the art and science of good learning design.

But if we think about not just a discrete learning experience, we’re learning gain in terms of measurable skill development or knowledge development is what we’re focused on, but more about learning as an ongoing practice that’s important for professionals. Thinking about convening, thinking about sustaining momentum over time becomes very, very important. I think a lot of the elements that Oldenburg studied, you know, whether that’s sort of like regulars at the bar. Regulars within a particular place, where people come together to learn, is a really interesting element if we think about ongoing facilitation. If we think about, not shabbiness exactly, but a low bar to entry, the “unfanciness” feeling of the space, was also something that I looked at in some of the research. How can we make places feel warm and comfortable when they’re digital? Or when we’ve put so much effort, as well, into designing aspects of digital learning in particular, to be engaging and effective and kind of slick and polished.

Actually, just on that one point, I love that you brought up Cheers, Randy, because one of my favorite studies in this more modern literature looking at ‘third places’ is actually called “Where Everyone Knows Your Username.” It’s an analysis of a massive online multiplayer game that had things like bars and libraries where people would look together. They did a sociological analysis of what features of some of those places tended to be aggregators of the people who were players in the game, and which ones drew people and which ones didn’t? How many of the factors that Oldenburg had identified in his research and analysis actually transferred over to the digital space as well. The answer is many of them did. The reason I bring it up is there are some aspects, whether we’re talking about accessibility or the slickness or high or low bar to entry; we need to think about them differently, in my opinion, when we think about digital gathering, not just physical.

Bradley Davis: Well, it’s so funny you say that because I’m sitting here, and I’m nodding aggressively because as a gamer, I’ve almost exclusively participated in gaming as ‘third places’, building multiple connections across countries, ethnicities, backgrounds, and areas. Some of my best friends I’ve met through my gaming experiences.

I thought it was really interesting because Oldenburg described qualities such as neutral ground, a leveling of status, conversation as the main activity, accessibility, regulars, and a playful atmosphere. It’s kind of core components, but I did notice that sometimes, and this again is really true in the gaming community, we missed that mark when it turns to creating that welcoming environment for any number of reasons. But we’re here to talk about learning, not gaming, as much as that disappoints me. I’m really curious to get your perspective. Which of those characteristics do you think that learning designers most overlook? And what would it look like for them to design that a little bit more intentionally?

Dr. Kelly Heuer: I love this question. So, I was mentioning low profile. As one of the factors I think can be hard to get the balance right on the digital learning. But what I actually think is probably the most overlooked of all of those factors is status leveling. I say that because I think so many times, even if we consider ourselves extremely progressive learning designers, and we’ve moved so far beyond the sage on the stage, the definition of a most facilitated learning experiences involve somebody with more expertise, imparting it to people who don’t already know the facts or have practiced the skills to this level of expertise.

So, a really good teacher, a really good facilitator, or a really good learning designer is thinking about trying to meet people where they are in a mixed levels context. Oftentimes the way you do that is by a show of hands—who’s been doing this for three years or two years or one year? And almost definitionally, to get things started, you’re positioning people relative to their own expertise, if you’re even doing that at all. A lot of times you’re “Well, everyone take a seat and the person who knows the things is going to say things to the people who don’t know the things.” I believe there are ways around this. I don’t think this is an insurmountable obstacle. That’s just the nature of a learning event. I think whether it’s a digital or a physical convening, things like what it says on your name tag. Does it say, “Hi, I’m Kelly Heuer” or “I’m vice president of learning, blah, blah, blah?” Or does it say, “Hi, I’m Kelly, here’s how you pronounce my name. Here’s one thing I’m curious about. Here’s one thing I’m working on.” Put titles last.

If you do know there are very mixed status power dynamics, oftentimes this can be true, especially if you’re within a particular organization or professional association. At convening the people who are more experienced, have those people introduce themselves last when you’re going around. What can you do to foreground the voices of those who have less experience or less status in this space? I think there are a number of different, small tweaks you can make that have a really big impact. But if you just let the organic nature of the way you’re trying to set things up carry through, power dynamics are going to reintroduce themselves almost immediately, and you might accidentally reinforce them in the service of trying to do a good job meeting learners where they’re at.

Randy Bowman: Those are some great ideas because in traditional learning experiences, so often we try to control the agenda, the instructor’s role, and the way people participate. And, you know, here at IACET, we like the idea of consistency. That’s part of what a quality learning management system affords people, the fact that the experience is consistent no matter what from time to time. So, we build that formality in. How, then, can we create structures needed for quality learning, but still maintain that openness, spontaneity, and relational connection that makes a ‘third place’ valuable?

Dr. Kelly Heuer: I think what I hear you elevating there, Randy, are things like the sense of play or a focus on conversation. If we’re going to stick in the frame of the ‘third place’ research, it can be hard to strike that balance, I think. But again, not impossible. There’s some research, not from sociology at all, but from the adjacent field of social psychology, that looks at people’s efficacy in the workplace. Stay with me; I’m going to bring this analogy back. It’s really changed the way I think about so many different things. This research looks at how people are perceived in the workplace, and there’s a sub-theme within this research focused specifically on how women are perceived. What they’re looking at are two different dimensions: competence and warmth. So, when I hear you asking, Randy, about playfulness and spontaneity—How do we make space for this to feel like a human experience while still driving learning home? What are we trying to get accomplished here? How can I skillfully navigate this cohort of learners to the end objective? How can I measure that I’ve actually done that work effectively? The body of research I’m familiar with, that I’m citing here, is looking at this tradeoff between competence and warmth as a trap if you view it as a false binary. Plenty of women are told, “Be tougher” or “Don’t be so smiley” or “Stop apologizing” or whatever. Those are all warmth signals. If you want to be taken more seriously at work, you need to act more like a competent person. But a lot of the findings looking at this, it’s a false dichotomy. You should still signal your own competence, own your voice, and drive the class to where you want to go, right?

What you do is just amp up your warmth signals at the same time. So I’m not trying to say, Randy, I think you’re drawing a false dichotomy. But when I think about tactics we can add, I don’t think fun and spontaneity are necessarily at odds with structure and clarity. I think it’s about finding ways to be playful while still advancing a point of view, like jokes if you’re in the right cultural context. Icebreakers that are both fun and help you drive a point you’re going for in the conversation you’re having. So it could be, “Here’s what I’m curious about, here’s what I’m working on.” Those are very generic ones, where you’re trying to lead with, “Who I am as a person.” But not just like, “What’s my favorite ice cream flavor.”

You can imagine variations on that, that are very closely related to the learning outcomes of what you’re working on, that allow you to pull on those threads of warmth and connectivity. Calling out people’s names, for example, or clustering people into groups on the basis of their answers to these questions. That can create a spirit of levity, but doesn’t undercut the seriousness of what you’re trying to do or the subject matter that you’re moving into. Those are some specific tactics that I’ve seen to be helpful. But the broader concept of amping up the warmth without diminishing anything about your goals and your objectives for that learning experience, I think has really been a big unlock for me in thinking about designing learning, and also thinking about a lot of things.

Bradley Davis: Honestly, I don’t think you could have set me up for a bigger segue if you tried, because, Kelly, one of the first things that really drew me to you as a presenter when we met at ASAE is your authenticity and how you really did level up both of those elements. You are that fun, amazing personality with the depth and intentionality. But there is no doubt in my mind that you are ready to scrap and rumble with the best of them as an instructional designer, curriculum developer, learning specialist, or even a learning strategist. But one of the things that we talked about when we first met, you raised an interesting point about how this hybrid work situation of remote work really is thinning out the idea of ‘second places’, which is, of course, the workplace where we spend a large majority of our time, and formal mentoring, professional friendships, and a sense of belonging that used to happen around the office almost by accident. I know that I’ve benefited through those tremendously throughout my career. In your opinion, what have we lost and what new responsibility does that create for associations and the learning functions of our organizations?

Dr. Kelly Heuer: Yeah, I hate to be one of those old people that’s like, “Well, in my day, this is how this happened. Our digital technology is ruining everything.” But, I’m sorry to say there are genuine downsides to the remote work revolution, and I say this as somebody who happily works remotely and probably would never want to go back to an office. I just think we need to be realistic about some of the tradeoffs. And they’ve been studied. So this is exactly as you said, Bradley, beautifully put. Randy, you were mentioning this in the opening. Hybrid work is one of several shifts that I think have really thinned out, this is a great way of describing it, the ‘second place’, the workplace.

So, if we imagine an abstract past where everyone works in an office, or on a work site, a job site, whatever your profession is. We have a long history of learning through apprenticeship or I call it learning through osmosis. When you begin, in most different career paths, you’re work tasks are more menial, but they also offer you a decent amount of exposure to different ways of working, different functional areas within your team or your organization. If I use project management as an example, because that’s a field that I’m very familiar with, you do status reports; you do meeting minutes. You have a lot of exposure to different decision makers. And a lot of the things that we learn early in our career, whether it’s like how to present yourself appropriately, or a genuine understanding of perennial conflicts: Why is marketing always angry at sales? Why is sales always mad at product? You can predict those patterns if you see them enough times. That’s where a lot of our more higher level areas of professional competence, whether it’s communication or empathy, are forged.

So, the pivot to remote work through the COVID pandemic and then afterwards, has removed a lot of those learning by osmosis opportunities. Now, that’s true. And a lot of those opportunities to learn organically by doing more, I call it menial tasks, but you know what I mean, lower level work; a lot of those are also being eroded by the rise of AI. Which is further taking away not just actual entry level jobs, but entry level tasks that helped a lot of us build the judgment that actually let us do higher level tasks over time. So this ‘second place’ is getting thinned out a lot, especially for people who are who are just starting out.

One of my favorite pieces of research about mentorship and osmotic learning, was done during this pivot to remote work in the coronavirus pandemic. It found what you would expect; this was at Microsoft, I think. They looked at engineering teams that used to be physically co-located and then were all working from home after the pandemic hit. They did an analysis of learning of junior engineers within mixed level teams. As you would expect, the junior engineers suffered a great deal, in terms of their performance over time, because they didn’t have the exposure to organic mentorship that they had from senior engineers. What I like about this study is because they had been looking at this already at Microsoft, they were also able to show that the senior engineers became more productive when they were spending less time mentoring junior engineers. So this learning by osmosis from near peers, it was never free. It’s just we had a ‘second place’ that better facilitated it in cases where the teams were co-located.

And so as we think about more remote distributed work, and we think about the acceleration of AI taking away a lot of these opportunities for feedback and practice with lower stakes, we have to be so much more deliberate about what it means to train and build skills there and find ways to introduce non-organic mentoring and other practice opportunities back in. I really think this is a talent pipeline issue that many organizations need to be thinking about seriously.

Randy Bowman: Wow, Kelly, you’ve just opened up a whole can of worms that we don’t have time to dive into. We’re definitely going to have to have you back for a part two. We are near the end of our time, though. So before we leave, we like to ask each and every one of our guests, “What does a world that learns better look like to you?”

Dr. Kelly Heuer: To me, a world that learns better makes learning possible for everyone, for people who are coming from all different walks of life, all different types of cognitive orientations, all different types of prior experiences. In my experience working in the learning field, almost everybody has a story as to why they became a teacher or they wound up here.

Oftentimes the story is “Traditional learning didn’t work for me,” for whatever reason that was. Neurodivergence, or you grew up poor, or you were learning in your second or third language, or you experienced some catastrophically life-altering event. There was something that made you need to take three steps back and think critically about the process of learning to figure out why it wasn’t working for you and if there was any kind of way around it. Then once you start doing that, that becomes fascinating. And if you solve it, if you’re able to fix that for yourself and continue to experience the transformative power of learning new things, you want that for other people, too. Education changed my life. I bet it changed your life. You want that for other people, but oftentimes there’s a story that drew people there. So, when I think about the goal that a lot of us have, as specialists in learning, it’s to make it more possible for more people, wherever you’re coming from, including if it’s where we were coming from once upon a time, to learn new things and to grow from it.

Randy Bowman: Wow, that’s awesome. Thank you so much, Kelly, for being here with us today and for sharing your insights and for helping us think about learning environments, not as just places where content is delivered, but as spaces where professional connection and community can take root. I have so many notes that I’ve jotted down. The one that I’m taking away most with me today is that connection is part of the learning design and that we need to be intentional about creating belonging, creating conversation, and peer connection just as much as we are concerned about learning outcomes. And I loved your ideas of starting small, asking learners to introduce themselves with something that they’re curious about instead of their job title. Those simple shifts, I think, are going to make it easier for everyone to contribute. Bradley, what was your key takeaway from the conversation today?

Bradley Davis: Well, unsurprisingly, as a gamer, I’m sitting here thinking about the status leveler concept and all the time that I’ve spent empowering and embracing and learning different groups and the massive multiplayer online communities. But there’s really something interesting to be said for Kelly’s last comment. There’s this component of realizing that the cost of the time that the individual, that mentor, the friend, the coach, what have you, who is investing in others. And I think as someone who doesn’t, frankly, give a good enough job about giving self-grace, there’s something important in acknowledging as a learning leader and embracing it because ultimately the time that you’re investing in those individuals is time well spent, because you’re spending it with folks who eagerly want to embrace being just 2% better than they were the day before.

Well, before we close, we’d like to bring this conversation back to our listeners and, hopefully, you’re finding just as many exciting tidbits as we did. But I’m curious to know, what is one thing your organization could change to make a learning experience feel more welcoming, conversational, and connected?

Randy Bowman: And don’t forget you can submit topic ideas, suggest guests, review our archives, and more at the CET Talks website available at cet-talks.org. Subscribe on your favorite podcast platform so you don’t miss a single episode. Thank you so much for joining us today.

Host: You’ve been listening to CET Talks, the official podcast of IACET. Don’t forget to subscribe to the podcast on Spotify, Apple podcasts, or wherever you listen to podcasts. To learn more about IACET visit iacet.org. That’s I-A-C-E-T.org. Thanks for listening, and we’ll be back soon with the new episode.  

Trending Now

Episode 5.2: The Third Place: Rethinking Learning Environments

Episode 5.1: Beyond Completion: Measuring What Learning Actually Achieves

Episode 4.13: The Other Side of the House: Accreditation, Certification, and the Value of Quality Assessment

Episode 4.12: Beyond the Gated Stereotype: Advocacy, Education, and the Heart of Community Management 

Episode 4.11: The Sensory-Sensitive Researcher Mom: How Data Collection at Home Helped Me Get Curious About Staff Needs

Episode 4.10: Talk to the Elephant: Designing Learning for Behavior Change

Episode 4.9: Letting It Go: Guidance and Growth Through Strategic Shedding

Episode 4.8: Learning That Counts: Credit for Prior Learning and the Future of Adult Education

Episode 4.7: Sustainability at the Center: Building a Better Business 

Episode 4.6: Workforce Ready: Trends, Credentials, and the Future of Economic Mobility 

Episode 4.5: At the Intersection of the World: Cross-Collaboration in Culture, Connection, and Comfort

Episode 4.4: Data and Datasets: Oversight and Insight Through Education Technology

Episode 4.3: Subject Matter, from Me to You: Professional Pivots from Learner to Leader

Episode 4.2: From Insight to Action: Moving Theory to Practice in Today’s Workforce Pipeline

Episode 4.1: Shredding the Paper Ceiling: Building the Case for Non-Degreed or Credentialed Workforce Development

Episode 31: Training Tomorrow’s Talent: Exploring Certification, Standards, and Impact with ATD’s Certification Institute

Episode 30: Silos to Synergy: Holistic Approaches to Creating Collaborative Learning

Episode 29: Credentials in Crisis: Challenges and Opportunities in Modern Education Recognition

Showing Slide 1 of 18: Episode 5.2: The Third Place: Rethinking Learning Environments

Leave a Reply